
Technique Extension tubes
52 |53
For my water droplet photos I use an
EF 100mm Macro lens with an EF 25 II
extension tube and manual focus to get the
biggest, clearest droplet possible. I always
use a tripod and work with natural light.
I shoot my water drop shots indoors as
it’s usually somewhat breezy where I live,
but I have good light from large windows.
I set up the flower with the background
positioned between 6 to 12 inches behind
it, depending on the desired result.
I place the water droplet on the petal
with a syringe and adjust the background
so that I can see it in the drop. It can be
a little time consuming, even frustrating,
to get a drop to a nice shape and make
it stay in place. The droplet has to be
positioned to get an unobscured view of
the background.
Sometimes I use printed matter such
as gift wrap or greeting cards to produce
the refracted image in the water droplet.
Designs with bright clear colours give the
clearest refractions. The image will be
inversed in the water drop. I position the
background sheet upside down so that
the design shows the right way up in the
refraction. I also like to use flowers – again
the brightest coloured flowers make the
clearest images.
Rodel Manabat Case studies
I have always been fascinated by macro
subjects, especially insects. I used to own
an EF 100mm f2.8 Macro lens, but it was
rather frustrating not being able to take the
shots I had in mind. So I sold my macro lens
and changed my set up to a more compact
solution. I now use an EF 12 II extension tube
with an EF 24-70mm f2.8L lens. It is easier,
quick to change and a great combination with
a fast aperture lens. It is a bit heavier than
the 100mm f2.8 Macro lens, but it serves a
dual purpose – a general walk around lens
and a good macro option (by attaching the
extension tube).
I like taking close-up and macro shots of
plants, leaves, flowers, petals, butterflies,
water droplets and insects – anything with
symmetry, lines and interesting texture.
Most of the time I use my EF 12 II tube with
my EF 24-70mm f2.8L. I normally shoot at the
70mm focal length. Using the rule of thumb
for calculating magnification (magnification
= extension/focal length), at 70mm the
magnification is 12mm/70mm = 0.17x.
I set the focusing to manual or automatic
depending on the subject. If the subject is
moving (such as insect, flower, plant, droplets
on leaves) then it is better to focus manually.
If your subject is fixed you can mount your
camera on a tripod, set autofocus and use
a shutter release cable to minimize camera
shake. I prefer to use a wider aperture (f2.8 to
f4) to draw attention to only a portion of the
subject. I use selective focusing from the 9
autofocus points of my camera. If there is too
much movement in the subject AI focusing is
of great advantage.
Flash is important. I used to ignore
using the camera’s built-in flash, but after
colleagues showed me the advantage of using
flash it has now become part of my set-up. I
also use a Speedlite 580EX II with a Stofen
OmniBounce diffuser.
Third party
EOS-fit extension
tubes are made by
other companies and
are less expensive
than those from
Canon. However, the
build quality can be
inferior and we have
not come across any
that are compatible
with EF-S lenses.
Canon extension
tubes maintain full
electrical contact
between the camera
body and lens, so
that you can stop
down the aperture
and, if you want to,
use autofocus. It
is possible to buy
extension tubes for
under £10, but the
catch is that they
have no electrical
contacts. You cannot
stop down your
lens and use a small
aperture as EF lenses
do not have manual
aperture rings. This
means that you will
be limited to using
your lens at its widest
aperture, unable to
increase the depth-
of-field.
Tube pros and cons
The big advantage of extension tubes is that
they can be used with nearly any lens. They
can also be used in combination with close-
up lenses (covered in the July–September
2010 issue), or with a macro lens, for even
greater magnifications.
Light loss
There is one major disadvantage – adding
an extension tube reduces the amount of
light reaching the film or digital sensor.
This means that you need to increase the
exposure by increasing the ISO, using a
slower shutter speed or setting a wider
aperture. Light loss can be as much as two
stops at higher magnifications – although
you always have the option of using off-
camera Speedlites so that you can use low
ISOs and small apertures. Both Lee Beel
and Rodel Mandabat, whose photos appear
in this article, use Speedlite flashes with
diffuses fitted to them for this reason.
Of course, much of the time you might
not be aware of this light loss. Unless you
are using the manual shooting mode, the
camera’s through-the-lens metering system
will automatically adjust the exposure values
to give correct exposure. However, it will
reduce your creative options for smaller
apertures or faster shutter speeds.
Focus shift
Another disadvantage occurs when you
use extension tubes with zoom lenses. If
you change the focal length of the lens, the
focusing distance changes as well, and you
need to refocus. You can get around this by
selecting the focal length you want to use
first (normally the longest) before focusing.
You don’t have this problem if you are
using a prime (fixed focal length) lens.
Telephoto lenses
Extension tubes work best with lenses that
have a focal length of between 35mm and
150mm. Below 35mm, you may need to
get so close to your subject to focus that it
becomes impractical. With longer telephoto
lenses, the increase in magnification is so
slight that using extension tubes may not
be useful. Canon’s 250D or 500D close-up
lenses will get you much closer.
Image quality
While Canon’s double element close-up
lenses, the 250D and 500D, are high quality
close-up lenses that have a minimal effect
on image quality, less expensive close-up
lenses can degrade image quality quite
badly. Extension tubes contain no glass and
so have little impact on image quality.
Above The
effectiveness of
adding extension
tubes depends on
two factors – the
focal length of
the lens and the
minimum focusing
distance. The shorter
the lens, and the
closer its minimum
focal distance, the
greater the level of
magnification will be
gained from adding
an extension tube.
May-lin Joe
The photos on this
page were taken using
an EF 24-70mm lens set
to 70mm and fitted with
an EF12 II extension
tube. The depth-of-
field is very narrow
but Rodel has used
this limitation to great
creative effect.
Above EOS 40D, EF
24-70mm f2.8L lens
with EF 12 II Extension
tube, ISO 100, f2.8, 1/40
second.
Right EOS 40D, EF 24-
70mm f2.8L lens with
EF 12 II Extension tube,
ISO 400, f2.8, 1/200
second.
Both Rodel and
May-lin can be
found online at
Flickr. You can
view their galleries
at www.flickr.
com/photos/
rodjbman71 and
www.flickr.com/
photos/mayj
respectively.
Comments to this Manuals